MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling) vs Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)
Side-by-side comparison — price, ABV, scores, tasting notes, pros & cons.
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling)
MacNair's
★ 5.00
£125
Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)
Signatory
£200
| MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling) | Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory) | |
|---|---|---|
| Distillery | MacNair's | Signatory |
| Region | — | — |
| Country | Scotland | Scotland |
| Type | Blended Malt | Single Malt |
| ABV | 48% | 57.9% |
| Age | 21 yr | 18 yr |
| Price | £125 | £199.95 |
| Rating | 5.00/5 | — |
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling)
Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling)
Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)
Quick verdict
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling) is rated higher (5.00 vs 0.00).
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling) is better value at £125 vs £200.
For beginners: Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory) is more approachable (50/100 beginner score).
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling)
Pros
- +Balanced smoky character without being overwhelming
- +Better value for money
- +Higher community rating (5.0/5)
- +More affordable (£125 vs £199.95)
Cons
- −Niche style — may not suit all palates
Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)
Pros
- +Approachable and beginner-friendly sweetness
- +Vibrant, fresh fruit character
Cons
- −High ABV (57.9%) — may need water
- −More expensive (£199.95 vs £125)
- −Lower community rating (0.0 vs 5.0)
Who should buy MacNair's?
MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling) suits whisky enthusiasts looking for a well-rounded, complex dram. It rewards those with some experience and an appreciation for Blended Malt character.
Who should buy Secret?
Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory) suits those who enjoy sweet, honeyed, or fruity whiskies. It's accessible for beginners and crowd-pleasing enough for gifts. Fans of approachable Speyside or Irish whiskey will love it.
Tasting notes
Both taste of
Only MacNair's Lum Reek 21 Year Old (Old Bottling)
Only Secret Speyside 18 Year Old 2005 (cask DRU17 A106 #9) - Cask Strength Collection (Signatory)